Ungrading: Why Rating Students Undermines Learning (and What to Do Instead) cover

Ungrading: Why Rating Students Undermines Learning (and What to Do Instead)

by Susan D. Blum (ed.)

Teachers who stopped grading, and what happened.

For you if

you suspect your kid is learning to chase points, not ideas.

⚡ Choose Your Route ⚡

Not sold directly on this site. Support indie bookstores with a new copy, or go sustainable with a used one.

Buy New on Bookshop.org

Supports independent bookstores

— OR —

Find Used on Better World Books

Secondhand & sustainable

$30 MSRP · Paperback
Reference price shown. Other editions may be available.

Teachers from kindergarten to graduate school describe what happened when they stopped grading. Students talked about what they learned, instead of what they could get away with. The essays are honest about the messes, the pushback from parents and the system that still demands a number, and give a working picture of school without grades.

Where This Book Lives

Pass with note. An edited collection, so the chapters vary in rigor and some are anecdote. The practical details are the value. Close relatives already in the catalog: Punished by Rewards, How Children Fail and Dumbing Us Down; this is the how-to to their why.

Related Viewing

Shares a topic, theme, or setting with this book in the catalog.

The Punk Singer poster

The Punk Singer(2013)

dir. Sini Anderson

Same themes: Collective Action, Community

Kathleen Hanna, riot grrrl, and what it cost.

The story of Kathleen Hanna, singer of Bikini Kill and Le Tigre, who helped start riot grrrl, and then went quiet at the height of her influence. Anderson uses interviews, performance footage and Hanna's own account of why she stopped and what came after. It is both a history of a movement and a portrait of the person who paid for it.

Why it’s here: The film shows how a movement is built by people with a photocopier and a loud voice. What's punk is the insistence that girls get to take up space and say the unsayable. What's pedagogical is the zine culture, the way the music was a tool for organizing and the way an art scene can be a school. Pairs with Notes from Underground, Please Kill Me and Bad Feminist. Note: it is an admiring portrait, and riot grrrl's whiteness and its limits are only touched on.

Where to watch: Criterion Channel (title page found); Kanopy via library listings; verify current US availabilityLetterboxd ↗

Crip Camp poster

Crip Camp(2020)

dir. Nicole Newnham & James LeBrecht

Same themes: Collective Action, Community

A summer camp that started a rights movement.

In the early 1970s, a ramshackle summer camp for teenagers with disabilities near Woodstock, Camp Jened, ran on hippie rules: no adults in charge of the kids' lives. The campers, among them co-director James LeBrecht and the future activist Judy Heumann, went on to organize the sit-ins and protests that helped win the Americans with Disabilities Act. It was produced for Netflix and was nominated for the Oscar for Best Documentary Feature.

Why it’s here: The film shows that a movement can begin as a summer. What's punk is that the people it follows organize without asking permission, and refuse to be treated as objects of pity. What's pedagogical is the through-line from a place where kids ran their own lives to a federal law that changed what was possible. It's a rare entry on disability and civil rights, and a natural fit for DoCR's self-organization principle.

Where to watch: Streaming on NetflixLetterboxd ↗